Tanzanite vs. Blue Topaz: A Comparison of December Birthstones

Whether you’re a December baby, a gemstone enthusiast, or simply looking for the perfect gift, this comparison will offer valuable insights. Tanzanite and Blue Topaz, the two December birthstones are as captivating as they are distinct. But how do these two gemstones differ, and which one suits you best? This article covers the unique characteristics, origins, and symbolism of tanzanite and blue topaz, helping you uncover the perfect match for your style and personality.

The Origin

From their mystical mining locations, these two gemstones each boast a unique history and origin. Let’s get to know about that.

Tanzanite, a once in a lifetime discovery: Discovered in 1967, Tanzanite has its origin from the foothills of mount Kilimanjaro in Tanzania. It has earned the nickname of “the gemstone of the 20th century” for its rarity (1000 times rarer than Diamond). With no known deposits elsewhere, this exclusive gemstone is a prized choice for collectors and jewelry enthusiasts.

Also Read: Modern Birthstone: Tanzanite is the Perfect Gift for December Borns

Blue Topaz, a global treasure: Found in various regions like Brazil, Nigeria and the United States, this blue gemstone has a more accessible charm. Discovered in the 18th century, the widespread availability of blue topaz has made it a popular and affordable option for jewelry, appealing to a broad audience without sacrificing its beauty or elegance. 

Comparing The Colors and Clarity

Tanzanite’s versatile spectrum: Tanzanite has a vivid trichroic nature. It stands apart from other blue gemstones by displaying three distinct colors: blue, violet, and burgundy, depending on the angle of light. The intermixing of dynamic shades creates an unmatched vibrancy and feast for the eyes. Tanzanite offers a sense of sophistication and mystery.

Blue Topaz’s poise: The sky blue, Swiss blue, and London blue hues portray a sense of calmness and serenity. While it lacks the dramatic color shifts of tanzanite, its clarity and brilliance make it an enduring favorite. This gemstone is appreciated by people who love understated elegance.

Durability and Everyday Wear

When investing in a particular gemstone, its durability and ease of maintenance plays a crucial role. Tanzanite and blue topaz differ significantly in their hardness and suitability.

Tanzanite: It records a hardness of 6 to 7 on the Mohs scale. This makes Tanzanite relatively soft than other gemstones and susceptible to scratches. With proper care and cleaning, you can wear it everyday. However, it is best suited for occasional wear or protective settings, such as pendants or earrings.

Also Read: Why is tanzanite a December birthstone?

Blue Topaz: Blue topaz boasts a higher hardness of 8, making it a more durable option for rings and other frequently worn jewelry. It is more affordable and a practical option for people who want longevity without compromising on beauty.

Symbolism and Meaning

Gemstones are often rich with symbolic meaning. Both tanzanite and blue topaz have unique meanings related to their colors and origins.

Tanzanite, a mystical story: Tanzanite is associated with inner transformation, healing and spiritual self discovery. It is said to help wearers unlock their potential and embrace new beginnings. It is a meaningful choice for people who seek enlightenment and growth in a spiritual sense.

Blue Topaz, a magical serenity: This beautiful blue stone represents clarity of thought, emotional balance and communication. Its soothing energy is believed to inspire honesty and deepen emotional connections, making it a wonderful gift for strengthening relationships.

Availability and Cost

The cost and easy availability is another major point of distinction between Tanzanite and Blue Topaz.

Tanzanite, rare, exclusive and expensive: Tanzanite tends to be more expensive due to its rarity and exclusivity. Especially the high carat and intense color versions of this gemstone make it a wished upon investment for collectors and jewelry lovers.

Also Read: Exploring Tanzania's Top 4 Gemstones

Blue Topaz, abundant and budget friendly: Blue Topaz is a budget friendly gemstone as it is found in abundance. However, this does not compromise with its visual appeal and elegance. Its affordability allows for larger stones and intricate designs, making it an accessible yet stunning option.

Which Gemstone Suits You The Best?

Now, you must be having this question in mind about which one of the two beautiful December birthstones suits you the best. Here are a few tips.

You can choose Tanzanite if:

1. You want a rare and exclusive addition in your collection.
2. You’re drawn to rich and vibrant hues, especially, blue, violet and burgundy.
3. You want a gemstone with a deep symbolic and spiritual significance.

You can choose Blue Topaz if:

1. You prefer a more affordable yet stunning gemstone.
2. You value durability, ease of maintenance and everyday wear.
3. You need a versatile and serene gemstone in your collection.

Final Words

While tanzanite dazzles with its rarity and vibrant hues, blue topaz captivates with its serene beauty and everyday practicality. Each of them bring their unique charm to the world of gemstones. Whether you’re selecting a piece for yourself or a loved one, either gemstone promises to add a touch of brilliance to your jewelry collection. So, will you choose the enigmatic allure of tanzanite or the tranquil elegance of blue topaz? Let your heart and instincts guide you to the best selection. We wish you a Merry Christmas and a happy holiday season!